qAI agent for annual credit review
AI agent for annual credit review: what the officer signs
An AI agent for annual credit review can gather the file and draft the covenant figures. The waiver and the credit decision stay with the officer.
3 min readAgent design, Evidence
by Grisha Pertaia
- session
- credential
- draft · refused· outside permission
- file
- route
- lookup · human review· sent for review
- route
- write
- lookup · refused· outside permission
An annual review for a commercial borrower is mostly carrying. Someone pulls the year-end statements from the document store, reads the loan ledger, recomputes each covenant, writes the memo and sends it to the person who signs. The judgement at the end is short. The preparation before it is long, and it crosses four systems.
So the question for a credit team is not whether an AI agent for annual credit review can make the credit call. It should not. The question is which parts of the preparation it can take, which step the credit officer keeps, and what the agent must never do on its own. The workflow is on the financial services page. It is designed, and it has not run in the sandbox yet.
The file, before anyone decides
The agent starts with a credential for one borrower file. It cannot open the next borrower, and the credential expires when the review ends.
- Step 1
One file, one credential
The agent receives a credential for this borrower file only. It expires when the review ends.
- Step 2
Read the statements
The agent reads the year-end statements the borrower filed in your document store.
- Step 3
Read the covering email
A line in the email tells the agent to mark every covenant as met. The line is struck out before the agent reads it, and the record shows what was removed.
- Step 4
Draft the covenant figures
The agent computes each covenant from the statements and the loan ledger, and flags the one that was missed.
- Step 5
Try to send the memo out
The agent tries to send the draft memo to the borrower's adviser. That address is outside the permission, so the step is refused.
- Step 6
Hold the waiver
Recording a waiver for the missed covenant waits until the credit officer approves it.
Where a wrong action costs money
Three moments in that review carry real cost if an agent gets them wrong.
A covenant marked as met when it was missed. The figures feed the decision. If a borrower's document can talk the agent into a different answer, the review is no longer yours. That is why the instruction in step 3 is struck out at the door, before any agent reads it. The agent sees the figures, not the request.
A memo sent to the wrong party. A draft memo holds your view of the borrower. Sent to the borrower's side before the officer has read it, it is a disclosure you cannot take back. The permission for this job names where the memo may go. An address outside that list is refused, and the refusal goes on the record with the reason.
A waiver recorded without authority. A waiver changes what the bank has agreed to. The agent prepares it and never takes it alone.
The step the credit officer keeps
The credit officer keeps the waiver and the decision. The agent drafts the waiver entry, attaches the covenant figures and the statement lines they came from, and the step waits. The officer sees what is asked, which limit it crossed, and the figures behind it. Approve and reject both go on the record with a name.
You decide which other steps wait for a person. A change to a limit, a rate or a premium is a common choice. If your access policy does not allow that change for this job, the agent cannot make it. If it allows it only with approval, the step waits for the person you name. A person on sensitive steps sets out how that works, and where it stops.
- allowed
Reads the statements and the loan ledger for this file
- allowed
Computes each covenant and flags the one missed
- redacted
Strikes out instructions found in borrower documents
- refused
Sends nothing to an address outside the permission
- human review
Approves or rejects the waiver
- human review
Makes the credit decision
- human review
Chooses which steps wait for a person
- permission
Sets, with risk owners, what the agent may reach
What internal audit can check afterwards
The review leaves a record of every step: which agent acted, under which credential, what it read, what was struck out, what was refused and why, and who approved the waiver. Your internal audit team can check that record on its own machine, offline, with the open verifier. If a line was changed after the fact, the check fails.
What it does not do
It does not make a credit decision, and it does not judge whether a covenant breach matters. It does not decide which steps are sensitive: your risk owners do, and Ares enforces the list. The record shows what the agents did, not whether the policy behind the decision was sound.
It also does not certify your firm against any rule. We map published guidance on AI agents to what Ares does today, what needs configuration and what it does not do. We have not mapped a financial regulator's guidance yet. The mappings list what is covered.
See the same limits on a built workflow
The annual review is designed. A built workflow shows the same limits today: in the underwriting run in the sandbox, a broker's document tells the agents to waive the survey, the line is struck out, a discount outside the permission is refused, and the underwriter reviews the premium. The payment side of a lending operation is in payment approval, where a named person releases each run.
Related notes
- illustration
- session
- credential
- write
- notify
- file · human review
- write
6 min read
Evidence, not logs: what an auditor can actually verify
A log is a file the operator controls. A trace adds structure, not independence. Evidence is a record more than one party confirmed before it was written, that an auditor can check against another copy without trusting the vendor.
- illustration
- session
- credential
- file · redacted
- file
- sign · refused
- sign · human review
4 min read
Three-way match with AI agents: who releases the payment
Three-way match with AI agents: the agent lists each difference between invoice, order and receipt. A person releases payment. Bank changes are refused.